Episode opens when Jeremy returns and confronts Mr. Shaffer and the household, accusing them of turning the home into a lawless den and ruining a girl's reputation while he was away. Sylvia is revealed to have gone on a blind date with Mr. Jensen; family says they "hit it off" and that she agreed to marry him. Sylvia now refuses, insisting she didn't consent. Relatives call her a tantrum and Mr. Shaffer refuses to believe her. Sylvia snaps, "I don't wanna be a rapist's family." The episode ends with the family split and the promised marriage suddenly in doubt.