Jimmy returns home to find a woman who claims she was sent by her boyfriend to celebrate a three-year anniversary but mistakenly ended up in Jimmy's bed. She insists Jimmy must take responsibility, citing her family's belief in lifelong love. Jimmy denies involvement, revealing he already has a fiancée who was left alone next door, risking their engagement. The woman tries to leave but is stopped by someone recognizing her and calling her 'Ms. Swift,' dropping a badge that surprises Jimmy. The episode ends with tension over the unexpected encounter and the looming consequences for Jimmy's relationship.