Two men at a party spot a woman in a red dress downstairs and both express interest in her. A dispute erupts when one man, Karen, asserts a prior claim, describing a past intimate encounter where she was covered in his marks and clung to him crying. His rival, Mason, is left silenced by the revelation, marking a sudden shift in the dynamic between the two. The episode ends with a different group expressing frustration over their own failed search, leaving both quests unresolved.