A man claiming to be Jeffrey stumbles into the Jamesons' house and is seized as family insist Jeffrey died after a cliff fall. Janice, his wife, accuses him of flirting and of colluding with Zack to murder Jeffrey. The claimant says he saw Jeffrey fall and protests his identity while an accuser takes a hair and vows a DNA test to unmask the impostor and link Jeffrey's death to the speaker's parents' deaths. Investigators say dashcam footage could reveal a car used to cover a murder. The episode ends with threats and the looming DNA and footage checks.