Carmen confronts Ben Lewis over their fractured family, insisting that their daughter Carmy is too important to be left fatherless. Tensions rise when Ben accuses Carmen of selfishness and threatens her with divorce, pointing out her financial dependence on him. Carmen strikes Ben in frustration, sparking further conflict over her mute condition and his absentee role in Adam's life. Ben warns her to back down or face consequences, while Carmen refuses to surrender, leaving their relationship hanging on a sharp edge. The episode ends with Carmy feeling abandoned, questioning her place without a father.