Henry has secretly protected Lisa for four years, but now James claims her, igniting conflict between the men. James insists Lisa belongs to him, dismissing Henry’s concerns about the Sherman family’s harshness. Henry struggles with the decision, warning against abandoning Lisa to James’s control after years of care. James remains unyielding while Lisa faces uncertain fate caught between them. The episode ends with Henry confronting James, but no resolution, leaving Lisa's future hanging in the balance.