Tensions flare when Jay's mother confronts him about doubts surrounding the paternity of Mia's child, accusing her of being unfaithful. Jay is pressured to reject Mia to avoid social shame, but Sasha challenges the accusations, demanding proof. The conflict escalates when a man appears claiming to be the biological father, revealing he spent a memorable night with Mia at a hotel ten months ago. Jay, shocked and conflicted, presses Mia for the truth, focusing on a distinctive scar as confirmation. The episode ends with Jay facing a devastating choice about who fathered the child.