When Matthew returns to Riverton, a woman eager to find him learns he is already married, forcing her to reconsider her plan. Meanwhile, Old Mr. Bridges reveals that the men in black working against the Tiptons were hired by someone else, a mystery he has pursued for 18 years. They attempt to interrogate the sick Mr. Blake for answers but find him nearly dead. Suddenly, news arrives that Cristal is in danger after a cut-off phone call. Without calling the police, Matthew insists on searching for her himself, racing to prevent further harm.