Three years after a bet involving Lady Cathy, Colin Milo vows to bring her back after his awkward confession scared her away. Colin races to the scene where he and his brothers, including Murphy and Rick Milo, confront Cathy about her secret marriage to Aron, who they claim is a 'kept man' despite Colin's backing. Cathy refuses to leave Aron, defending her new life. The brothers present evidence that Aron has cheated on her, sparking denial and anger. The episode ends with Aron suggesting they get a divorce, leaving their relationship on shaky ground.