Mr. Shaw confronts a woman he believes is Joy, his late wife's lookalike, but she denies it, claiming her name is Zoey and insisting they are not the same person. Despite their identical appearances and voices, she maintains the lie, having used a fake name during their previous encounter. Others, including Zoey and someone at the scene, suggest Mr. Shaw is mistaken due to grief and stress, emphasizing that Zoey has lived locally all her life and rarely leaves home. Mr. Shaw demands an explanation, unwilling to accept their denials, leaving the mystery unresolved as tensions rise.