Rosie returns to the Sullivan family after 20 years of hardship and immediately faces tension over a seat offered by Willa. Although she was shunned and treated as a jinx in her past life, Rosie challenges the family's favoritism towards Willa, claiming her rightful place. Her confrontation escalates as the family accuses her of ingratitude, but Rosie demands recognition for her suffering and rejection. The patriarch expresses frustration over the divided loyalties, and Rosie, feeling abandoned, declares she wants new parents, setting the family conflict on a new, unresolved path.