Ms. Shaw and Cal rush to a hospital after being told 'that mute' who was reportedly gone is found injured and pregnant but alive and speaking. When she stirs, someone panics: 'If she speaks up about the phone call back then, I'll be ruined.' Cal and others call her Alyssa, but the woman loudly insists, "I'm not Alyssa!" Another voice then insists Alyssa died six years ago. The contradiction escalates into confusion and accusation as the group faces a living woman who could expose the old phone call - and the episode ends with her identity and the threatened exposure unresolved.