Hilda secretly gets a hymenoplasty to hide her sexual past and save her father, then lies to her boyfriend Joey about being in her hometown to fetch documents when he calls. She plans to act innocent and use the car ride to conceal the surgery. At a gathering Joey brings his best friend, Mr. Schroeder, and introduces Hilda as "my girl." The man turns out to be Hilda's ex-boyfriend, a shock that immediately links her past to Joey's inner circle. The episode ends with Hilda exposed to her ex in front of Joey, leaving her next move uncertain.