A tense restroom confrontation opens the episode: a woman declares, "I'm Joey's girlfriend," and accuses Mr. Schroeder of sleeping with Joey; he deflects, claims time abroad and refuses to accept they're broken up. The argument momentarily stalls as they awkwardly try to "start over," then the narrative cuts to the narrator's memory of meeting Carroll at twenty-one—falling in love, planning to marry, giving him everything. The mood flips to panic—shouts of "Run!" and hurried talk of showers—then the narrator reveals that one day Carroll simply disappeared, leaving the accusation and the sudden flight unresolved.