A storm warning opens the episode as Lily is grabbed in Shawn's car on the highway; he orders her out after she glances at a ripped guy. He drives recklessly, eyes red, then kicks her out to avoid frightening her. Flashback: seven years earlier, college Lily chased Shawn with flowers, breakfast and ninety-nine love letters but he rejected her and classmates mocked her. When she was ready to quit, live comments appeared claiming Shawn is madly in love and hides hundreds of her photos. Back in the rain, Shawn speeds away, leaving Lily stunned and unsure whether to confront him.