At a family gathering Joyce erupts, demanding her fiancé back and calling Tina, the Charles family's illegitimate daughter, an intruder. Joyce insists Scott is her husband; Tina pushes back, admitting she once forced Scott to marry her to keep him out of prison and says she can never let Scott know the truth. When Joyce escalates, Tina pulls a knife and forces Scott to answer who he loves; under pressure he blurts, "It's you." Joyce then asks if he ever loved her in five years; he says "Never," and Joyce storms out, leaving Tina's secret intact.