Ben, a recent graduate, undergoes a post-operative rectal exam performed by his stepbrother Ethan, the proctologist. Overwhelmed with embarrassment, Ben tries to leave, but Ethan insists on completing the checkup, suggesting alternative methods. As Ethan introduces a warm, unfamiliar instrument, Ben is flooded with discomfort and confusion, protesting the intrusion. The episode culminates with Ben's realization that his recent spicy meal and his strained, distant relationship with his stepbrother have led to this intensely awkward and vulnerable medical encounter.