On the morning after her wedding, Dolly—newly married into the Stevens family—faces a shock: staff claim the man who spent the night with Mrs. Stevens sounded like Jerome. Rumors said Jerome is cold, but the wedding night had been unexpectedly gentle. Servants accuse the household of letting an unknown man into the house. Jerome insists he slept in the guest room and denies interest in women, while others confront a man and demand, "You were the man last night, weren't you?" The household is split and the episode ends as everyone asks, "Who was that man?"