A tussle erupts when Scott grabs a book from Leah — she says Old Mrs. Zale gave it to her after she helped clean. Scott shoves Leah and taunts her and her mother, accusing them of jinxing Uncle Arthur’s death and denying Leah the right to read. Nicole pushes Scott in response, sparking adults' outrage and a debate over whether an adult should hit a child. Onlookers note Scott is "pretending" and someone declares, "You're Kevin now. I'm your wife," revealing identity confusion. The episode ends with Kevin and Rachel asked to decide, the verdict still pending.