On a live-streamed Life Simulation show, Mandy Jean confronts the 30-year mystery around Sheila Jean: viewers and family accuse Sheila of cleaning up her parents' murder, hiding evidence, abandoning the family—selling their possessions, driving their grandmother to death, and becoming a gambler and criminal. Accusations escalate into a consensus that Sheila was cowardly, not protective. Mandy triggers a Life Simulation PK restart and signs on as participant to simulate Sheila on Thanksgiving night. The episode ends as the simulation goes live and multi-platform viewers start voting to decide who is the better big sister.