Xander, feeling isolated and angry after being cut off from the Smith family, retreats to an empty attic where Yara introduces a wishing tree to share their thoughts. Meanwhile, the Smith family debates whether to pursue him, arguing over the harshness of their rejection. Despite gifts and birthday wishes, Xander is confronted with accusations of ingratitude and demands he apologize to another family member, Hayden. As tensions rise, Xander finds himself torn between resentment and family expectations, while the attic stands as a silent reminder of a fractured bond. The episode ends with an uneasy silence, hinting at unresolved conflict.