Xander is missing, and his siblings discover the lights in his room are off, despite his fear of the dark. Samuel claims Xander is no longer afraid since Mr. Smith emerged from a cabinet, but others accuse Samuel of locking Xander inside the cabinet as punishment. Mr. Smith reveals he was trapped in the cabinet for a day and nearly didn’t survive the darkness. The family regrets neglecting him and vows to treat Xander like their own son. As they try to contact Xander, his phone is unreachable, leaving his return and fate uncertain.