Sophie, a childhood friend of Travis, shows up with desserts and says Melissa invited her in and stayed for dinner. Melissa is startled that Travis kept Sophie a close secret. Sophie recalls Travis cooking for her when she was picky and later brings chicken soup when Melissa feels unwell. Over dinner Sophie brings up the couple's chosen baby names and promises to "fix the mistakes" she made, which provokes Melissa to demand she leave. The episode ends when Sophie cries, "It hurts so bad!" and people rush in, leaving her fate unresolved.