At Sophie Quinn's home, Sophie and a man playfully insist they are Lucky's "mommy" and "daddy" while David arrives with a box of treats. They banter about spoiling the dog, hurry him out to exercise, and enjoy a brief reunion. The mood flips when two visitors knock and ask if this is Sophie Quinn's address. After she confirms, they report someone called and accused her of stealing the dog. They tell her, "You'll need to come with us to the police station to make a statement." Sophie is stunned as the playful household faces an official theft allegation.