Shaina's sudden return alarms Mia and her mother, who dismiss her yet fear she could rekindle things with Jason/Mr. Yale. Mia's mother vows to block Shaina and 'take out her brazen mother' while arranging a Yale marriage for Mia. At Cosmos Law Firm coworkers gossip about Mr. Yale's lost first love and press Shaina; she insists they never knew each other. After a strained lunch she slips to the restroom. The episode ends when someone finds her and says, "You finally found me, my dear little sister," leaving a surprising personal connection unresolved.