Rhea's parents arrive after Ollie warned them she was in trouble; Dad has wrecked the door. Rhea tells her mother she's fine and will "play along a little longer," while others press for answers. Ollie insists he's not lying: "I swear I saw Jeff Payne coming in here!" Mr. Catton is urged not to let him off easy. Adam notices a foul smell and they find a trash bin tucked under Rhea's desk. The discovery sharpens the dispute and forces the household to decide whether to act on Ollie's claim about Jeff Payne.