Grandma returns after six years. Toby refuses to greet her, shouting "I hate Grandma" and accusing her of causing his punishments, which forces Justin and his mother to confront him about manners and upbringing. Grandma inspects Toby's trophies and hands, bluntly declaring the awards lies - "no talent for singing," "never practiced piano." Mom defends Toby and insists Grandma attend his competition tomorrow to see for herself. Justin hustles Toby upstairs to rehearse. The family is left divided and tense, with tomorrow's performance set to decide who is right but still unresolved.